Dec 14, 2025
1 Upcoming Shows
Select a showtime to buy tickets from Ticketmaster
It’s CSI: Bethlehem in this holiday mystery extravaganza, by the author of the Late Nite Catechism series, as Sister takes on the mystery that has intrigued historians throughout the ages-whatever happened to the Magi’s gold? Retelling the story of the nativity, as only Sister can, this hilarious holiday production is bound to become a yearly classic. Bring your cameras because in Sister’s Nativity, your mother might be cast as the Virgin Mary, or your husband as the Ass!
By becoming a Shea’s Season Subscriber, you not only ensure your tickets to the hottest Broadway ticket in town, but you receive many benefits; including but not limited to early access to additional seats, firsthand knowledge of upcoming shows, upgrades and more. Become a Season Subscriber today and become part of our legacy.
Get Updates From Shea's
A planned or estate gift can be of any size, and it’s easier than you think to make your gift a reality. Investing in the future of Shea’s through planned giving is a generous way to ensure our glorious theatre remains a gift to Buffalo for many years to come.
For your convenience and safety, we're moving away from paper tickets. Your phone is now your ticket! This shift will enhance your experience at Shea’s Buffalo Theatre by providing a contactless and more eco-friendly way to enter our theater safely and efficiently, while also reducing the risk of lost, stolen, or counterfeit tickets.
Welcome to Shea's Smith Theatre! Shea’s Smith Theatre, formerly Laube’s Old Spain Restaurant, established in the year 2000. It has transformed into a viable 200 seat black box theater, hosting Off-Broadway productions, comedians, and collaborative productions with local theatre companies.
