It’s CSI: Bethlehem in this holiday mystery extravaganza, by the author of the Late Nite Catechism series, as Sister takes on the mystery that has intrigued historians throughout the ages-whatever happened to the Magi’s gold? Retelling the story of the nativity, as only Sister can, this hilarious holiday production is bound to become a yearly classic. Bring your cameras because in Sister’s Nativity your mother might be cast as the Virgin Mary, or your husband as the Ass!
Dec 23, 2026
1 Upcoming Shows
Select a showtime to buy tickets from Ticketmaster
The Shea's Box Office is open two hours prior to any performance and during intermission.
The Shea's Bistro & Bar lobby will open one hour before, with house opening thirty minutes before show-time.
Download the app to find your tickets to Shea's and a Sheabill for your show already waiting here.
Walk-through metal detection screening process is in effect for all patrons.
Don't miss a moment at Shea's. Season Subscribers get early ticket access, exclusive perks, and insider updates on upcoming shows.
Join Our Email List
