The Betsy Carmichael Christmas Special

The Betsy Carmichael Christmas Special, Buffalo’s favorite interactive holiday comedy, for a limited engagement at Shea’s Smith Theatre, December 18–20, 2026.

The Betsy Carmichael Christmas Special has delighted audiences for nearly a decade with its unique blend of comedy, holiday cheer, audience participation, music, and, of course, BINGO. The production returns for four performances only: Presented at Shea’s Smith Theatre in Buffalo’s Theatre District.

Betsy Carmichael, Buffalo’s self-proclaimed “First Lady of BINGO,” returns with her Ho-Ho-Hilarious holiday spectacular filled with outrageous characters, festive fun, prizes, surprises, and enough Christmas spirit to fill Santa’s sleigh. Part holiday variety show, part comedy event, and part interactive BINGO extravaganza, The Betsy Carmichael Christmas Special has become a beloved seasonal tradition for audiences throughout Western New York. Betsy and her BINGO adventures have entertained sold-out audiences in Buffalo and beyond, with appearances in cities including Chicago, Pittsburgh, Providence, Indianapolis, and Cleveland.

Critics have embraced Betsy’s unique brand of holiday entertainment:

“A cross between the old Judy Garland Christmas Special and the Pee-Wee Herman Show.” — New York Theatre Guide

“A perfect marriage of the naughty and nice.” — The Buffalo News

“The Best BINGO Show Ever!” — Mix 96 Buffalo

“An amazing show with an incredible cast!” — Totally Buffalo